A Border Dispute: The Place of Logic in Psychology by John Macnamara

By John Macnamara

A Border Dispute integrates the most recent paintings in common sense and semantics right into a idea of language studying and provides six labored examples of ways that conception revolutionizes cognitive psychology. Macnamara's thesis is decided opposed to the historical past of a clean research of the psychologism debate of the 19th-century, which ended in the present standoff among good judgment and psychology. The e-book provides psychologism throughout the writings of John Stuart Mill and Immanuel Kant, and its rejection through Gottlob Frege and Edmund Husserl. It then works out the overall thesis that common sense preferably offers a competence conception for a part of human reasoning and explains how logical instinct is grounded in homes of the brain. the following six chapters current examples that illustrate the relevance of common sense to psychology. those difficulties are all within the semantics of kid language (the studying of right names, own pronouns, sortals or universal nouns, quantifiers, and the truth-functional connectives) and replicate Macnamara's wealthy history in developmental psychology, quite baby language - a box, he issues out, that embraces all of cognition. Technical difficulties raised by way of yet now not incorporated within the examples normally a part of the textual content are handled in a separate bankruptcy. The ebook concludes via describing legislation in cognitive psychology, or the kind of technological know-how made attainable by means of Macnamara's new idea. A Bradford booklet.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Border Dispute: The Place of Logic in Psychology PDF

Similar cognitive books

Neural Plasticity and Cognitive Development: Insights from Children with Perinatal Brain Injury

The arrival of recent neurobiological equipment over the past 3 a long time has supplied overwhelming proof that it's the interplay of genetic components and the event of the person who courses and helps mind improvement. Brains don't advance often within the absence of serious genetic signaling, and so they don't advance in general within the absence of crucial environmental enter.

Cognitive Science: An Introduction to the Mind and Brain

Cognitive technological know-how is a huge new consultant to the principal theories and difficulties within the learn of the brain and mind. The authors truly clarify how and why cognitive technology goals to appreciate the mind as a computational method that manipulates representations. They establish the roots of cognitive technological know-how in Descartes - who argued that each one wisdom of the exterior global is filtered via a few kind of illustration - and look at the present-day position of synthetic Intelligence, computing, psychology, linguistics and neuroscience.

Perception, Cognition, and Language: Essays in Honor of Henry and Lila Gleitman

Those unique empirical examine essays within the psychology of notion, cognition, and language have been written in honor of Henry and Lila Gleitman, of the such a lot renowned psychologists of our time. The essays variety throughout fields foundational to cognitive technology, together with notion, recognition, reminiscence, and language, utilizing formal, experimental, and neuroscientific methods to problems with illustration and studying.

Additional resources for A Border Dispute: The Place of Logic in Psychology

Example text

Finally, we must abstract from the particulars of the device that seeks to apply the competence. There are infinitely many ways in which any set of rules, any competence, can be instantiated in a device that produces strings of words in accordance with those rules.  A theory of competence for English aims to characterize the set as a whole without specifying how English rules are realized in my head.  28) sees the universal grammar as supplied by nature, rather than as learned, the relevant idealization is that universal grammar is uniform across individuals and complete in each one.

Take the Irish sentence Tá ceithre chos faoi mhadra and its English translation A dog has four legs.  The attempt to handle interpretation by means of sentences alone leads to an infinite and pernicious regress.  Although we must employ a sentence to state its form, a procedure itself is not a sentence but a device that performs a certain operation.  Nevertheless, interpreters are like procedures in that they are not sen­ Page 36 tences or beliefs but devices that place the mind in intentional contact with the objects that form the semantic content of some linguistic expression.

The competence that is universal grammar is mainly knowledge of the possibilities for natural language.  It is fair to say, however, that he has not been explicit enough in his recent writing to reverse the impression that universal grammar consists of knowledge­that.  The main task for linguists and psychologists of language alike is to establish the true theory of linguistic competence.  The relevant set is linguistic competence.  We will not concern ourselves with this claim.  In fact it may take generations on generations of linguists to sift intuition so that it leads to a correct characterization of competence.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.63 of 5 – based on 24 votes